Difference between revisions of "Top Level Ontology"

From D4Science Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(→‎MarineTLO Evaluation)
(→‎Releases)
 
(100 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
== Latest (June 2013) slide presentation  ==
+
== Introduction ==
−
*https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=60ecbc87-fee1-4d98-9acb-beb9596289a4
+
  
−
== Person responsible for editing/maintaining this page==
+
=== In a nutshell ===
 +
One of the main characteristics of biodiversity data is its cross-disciplinary feature and the extremely broad range of data types, structures, and semantic concepts which encompasses. Moreover, biodiversity data, especially in the marine domain, is widely distributed, with few well-established repositories or standard protocols for their archiving, access, and retrieval.  Queries like ''“Given the scientific name of a species, find its predators with the related taxon-rank classification and with the different codes that the organizations use to refer to them"'', cannot be formulated (and consequently nor answered) by any individual source. To formulate such queries we need an expressive conceptual model, while for answering them we also have to assemble pieces of information stored in different sources.
 +
To fill this gap, we have designed and implemented a top level ontology, called '''Marine Top Level Ontology''' (for short '''MarineTLO''').
  
−
* Carlo Allocca (carlo@ics.forth.gr)
+
=== Motivating Scenarios ===
 +
The availability of a top level ontology for the marine domain would be useful in various scenarios. Below we will describe them.
  
−
== TLO-Development activity ==
+
'''For Publishing Linked Data:''' There is a trend towards publishing Linked Data; consequently a rising issue concerns the structure that is beneficial to use during such publishing. The semantic structure that will be presented can be used by the involved organizations for anticipating future needs for information integration, and thus alleviating the required effort for (post) integration.
  
 +
'''For Generating Fact Sheets:''' FactSheetGenerator is an application provided by IRD aiming at providing factual knowledge about the marine domain by mashing-up relevant knowledge distributed across several data sources. Currently, FactSheetGenerator uses only ECOSCOPE and related knowledge stored in other sources (e.g., about commercial codes or taxonomic information) cannot be exploited. MarineTLO could be exploited for advancing this application, i.e., for providing more complete semantic descriptions.
  
−
=== General Description ===
+
'''For Semantic Post-Processing of the Results of Keyword Search Queries:''' Another big challenge nowadays is how to integrate structured data with unstructured data (documents and text). The availability of harmonized structured knowledge about the marine domain can be exploited for a semantic post-processing of the search results (over dedicated or general purpose search systems). [http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/XSearch XSearch] is a meta-search engine that offers semantic post-processing of search results and is able to analyze the returned results by exploiting also the availability of semantic repositories (e.g. SPARQL endpoints). Xsearch could exploit MarineTLO for providing more complete information about the identified entities.
  
−
This activity concerns with the development of a top level ontology (called MarineTLO) that will integrate the concepts currently existing in marine-domain knowledge bases (in particular FLOD and ECOSCOPE knowledge bases). The MarineTLO-development activity is dived into six sub-activities (or Tasks) and related to each other as shown in the diagram in Fig 1.  
+
'''For Enabling Complex Query Services over Integrated Data:''' MarineTLO can be used as the schema for setting up integrated repositories that offer more complex query services, which cannot be supported by the individual underlying sources. In general, there are two main approaches for building and querying such repositories: the materialized integration approach (or warehouse approach), and the virtual integration (or mediator) approach (more information about these approaches can be found in '''[Tzitzikas-MTSR'13]'''). The key point is that in both cases we need a schema and MarineTLO can serve this requirement.
  
 +
== MarineTLO as a product ==
  
 +
We used a set of underlying sources for integrating their concepts in MarineTLO. Below we briefly describe these sources, and then describe the ontology MarineTLO and its corresponding releases.
  
−
[[File:Pic1.png|center]]
+
=== The main underlying sources ===
  
−
=== Methodology ===
+
'''Fisheries Linked Open Data:''' FLOD, created and maintained by Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), is dedicated to create a dense network of relationships among the entities of the Fishery domains, and to programmatically serve them to semantic and traditional application environments. The FLOD content is exposed either via a public SPARQL endpoint[http://www.fao.org/figis/flod/endpoint] (suitable for semantic applications) or via a JAVA API to be embedded in consumers’ application code. Currently, the FLOD network includes entities and relationships from the domains of Marine Species, Water Areas, Land Areas, Exclusive Economic Zones, and serves software applications in the domain of statistics and GIS.
  
−
It is based on an Iterative and Incremental development approach. As such, one iteration will involve all the above tasks that are described here http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/Top_Level_Ontology. All the iterations will be accurately described and new MarineTLO version will be delivered in each iteration.
+
'''ECOSCOPE Knowledge Base:''' IRD  offers a public SPARQL endpoint[http://ecoscopebc.mpl.ird.fr/joseki/ecoscope] for its knowledge base containing geographical data, pictures and information about marine ecosystems (specifically data about fishes, sharks, related persons, countries and organizations, harbors, vessels, etc.).
  
−
=== Activities scheduled with deadlines ===
+
'''WoRMS:''' The World Register of Marine Species[http://www.marinespecies.org] currently contains more than 200 thousand species, around 380 thousand species names including synonyms, and 470 thousands taxa (infraspecies to kingdoms).
  
−
Each iteration is planned to be monitored by opening related tickets.
+
'''FishBase:''' FishBase[http://www.fishbase.org] is a global database of fish species. It is a relational database containing information about the taxonomy, geographical distribution, biometrics, population, genetic data and many more. Currently, it contains more the 32 thousand species and more than 300 thousand common names in various languages.
  
−
=== Related Cluster ===
+
'''DBpedia:''' DBpedia[http://dbpedia.org] is a project focusing on the task of converting content from Wikipedia to structured knowledge so that Semantic Web techniques can be employed against it. At the time of writing this article, the English version of the knowledge base of DBpedia describes more than 4.5 million things, containing persons, places, works, species, etc. In our case, we are using a subset of DBpedia’s knowledge base containing only fishes (i.e. instances classified under the class <nowiki>http://dbpedia.org/ontology/Fish</nowiki>).
−
http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/Semantic_cluster_achievements
+
  
−
=== Related Wiki Pages ===
+
=== The Marine Top Level Ontology ===
−
http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/XSearch
+
  
 +
MarineTLO is not supposed to be a single ontology covering the entirety of what exists. It aims at being a global core model that (a) covers with suitable abstractions the domains under consideration to enable the most fundamental queries, (b) can be extended to any level of detail on demand, and (c) can adequately map and integrate data originating from distinct sources. This approach has two main benefits:
 +
* reduced effort for improving and evolving it since the focus is given on one model rather than many
 +
* reduced effort for constructing mappings since this approach avoid the pair-wise mappings between individual metadata formats and/or ontologies.
  
−
== Motivation - Goal - Requirements ==
+
For the development and evolution of MarineTLO we have adopted an iterative and incremental methodology comprising the following steps: (i) ontological analysis of the underlying sources, (ii) design, (iii) implementation and (iv) evaluation. The activities of each iteration has been monitored by opening the corresponding tickets. The section [[#Related_tickets]] contains a list of the tickets that have been opened. For the implementation of MarineTLO we have used OWL 2 (Web Ontology Language) while for the needs of evaluation we used the notion of competence queries.
−
Describe a scenario that will justify the need for having such a MarineTLO on top of marine-domain knowledge bases.
+
  
−
THE MOTIVATIONS ARE BASED ON THE FACT THAT:
+
=== Releases ===
−
Semantic technologies, applications and services for biodiversity mostly rely on the rise of an interconnected and shared tree-of-life like dataset scaling on the web. The various communities (including also marine one) are contributing to this joint effort aim to share domain data and their meaning, to provide a solid basis for biodiversity systems interoperability.  
+
In total we have released 4 versions of the MarineTLO. Each release was able to cover various concepts for different sources. Below we report the contents, some basic information, and several links (e.g., documentation) of each version.  
  
−
THE GOAL IS:
+
{| border="1" class="wikitable"
−
Our goal in modelling and formalising a Top Level Ontology (MarineTLO) is for '''integrating''' and '''semantically extending''' the underlying models of existing marine data sources. Specifically, the MarineTLO is used on the top of a number of real and heterogeneous marine data sources, including FLOD and ECOSCOPE, as knowledge mediator to represent, manipulate and reason upon and across them.
+
|+ MarineTLO Versions
 +
! Version
 +
! Classes and Properties
 +
! Underlying Sources
 +
! Concepts covered
 +
! OWL File
 +
! Documentation
 +
! Mappings
 +
! Competence Queries
 +
! Release Date
 +
|-
 +
! Version 1
 +
| 17 classes and 8 properties
 +
|| FLOD, ECOSCOPE, WORMS
 +
|| Species, Scientific Names, Predators
 +
|| http://goo.gl/ukxmAv
 +
||
 +
|| http://goo.gl/kEfp8g
 +
|| http://goo.gl/3sMdwR
 +
|| March 2013
 +
|-
 +
! Version 2
 +
| 57 classes and 22 properties
 +
|| FLOD, ECOSCOPE, WORMS, DBpedia
 +
|| Species, Scientific Names, Predators, Authorships
 +
|| http://goo.gl/JTh8p9
 +
|| http://goo.gl/Y9bGFy
 +
|| http://goo.gl/I6STNv
 +
|| http://goo.gl/3ZNqb4
 +
|| July 2013
 +
|-
 +
! Version 3
 +
| 57 classes and 25 properties
 +
|| FLOD, ECOSCOPE, WORMS, DBpedia, Fishbase
 +
|| Species, Scientific Names, Common Names, Predators, Authorships, Ecosystems, Countries, Water Areas, Vessels, Gears, EEZ
 +
|| http://goo.gl/J15OCE
 +
|| http://goo.gl/FygSd6
 +
|| http://goo.gl/vxESUF
 +
|| http://goo.gl/yTaz7O
 +
|| October 2013
 +
|-
 +
! Version 4
 +
| 127 classes and 81 properties
 +
|| FLOD, ECOSCOPE, WORMS, DBpedia, Fishbase
 +
|| Species, Scientific Names, Common Names, Predators, Authorships, Ecosystems, Countries, Water Areas, Vessels, Gears, EEZ, Bibliography, Statistical Indicators
 +
|| http://goo.gl/Yh1Uot
 +
|| http://goo.gl/KIFY6e
 +
|| http://goo.gl/WU3xkG
 +
|| http://goo.gl/KIFY6e
 +
|| July 2014
 +
|}
  
−
THE REQUIREMENTS ARE:
+
== References ==
−
This Top Level Ontology has to focus on EAF ( Ecosystem Approach to Fisheries / Marine Resources) and should be generic enough to provide consistent abstractions or specifications of concepts included in all data models  or ontologies of iMarine data sources such as '''ECOSCOPE''', TDWG-WORMS, '''FLOD''', AGROVOC, DwC, IBIS [Gangemi 2002], [Doerr 2003], and provide the necessary properties to make this distributed knowledge base a coherent source of facts relating observational data with the respective spatiotemporal context and categorical (systematic) domain knowledge
+
  
−
== Related Meetings (and their slides) ==
+
=== Related Links/Publications ===
 +
* MarineTLO public website http://www.ics.forth.gr/isl/MarineTLO/
 +
* MarineTLO-based Warehouse wiki page http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/MarineTLO-based_warehouse
 +
* <b>[Tzitzikas-MTSR'13]</b> Y. Tzitzikas, C. Alloca, C. Bekiari, Y. Marketakis, P. Fafalios, M. Doerr, N. Minadakis, T. Patkos and L. Candela. <i>Integrating Heterogeneous and Distributed Information about Marine Species through a Top Level Ontology</i>, Proceedings of the 7th Metadata and Semantic Research Conference, MTSR'13, Thessaloniki, Greece, November 2013.
 +
* <b>[Tzitzikas-ERCIM'14]</b> Y. Tzitzikas, C. Allocca, C. Bekiari, Y. Marketakis, P. Fafalios and N. Minadakis. <i>Ontology-based Integration of Heterogeneous and Distributed Information of the Marine Domain</i>, ERCIM News 2014 (96), Special theme: Linked Open Data, January 2014
 +
* <b>[Tzitzikas-LWDM'14]</b> Y. Tzitzikas, N. Minadakis, Y. Marketakis, P. Fafalios, C. Alloca and N. Mountantonakis. <i>Quantifying the Connectivity of a Semantic Warehouse</i>, 4th International Workshop on Linked Web Data Management, LWDM'14, Athens, Greece, March 2014.
 +
* <b>[Moutantonakis-PROFILES'14]</b> M. Mountantonakis, C. Allocca, P. Fafalios, N. Minadakis, Y. Marketakis, C. Lantzaki and Y. Tzitzikas. <i>Extending VoID for Expressing the Connectivity Metrics of a Semantic Warehouse</i>, 1st International Workshop on Dataset Profiling & Federated Search for Linked Data (PROFILES'14), in conjunction with the 11th Extended Semantic Web Conference (ESWC'14), Anissaras Hersonissou, Crete, Greece, May 2014.
 +
* <b>[Tzitzikas-ESCW'14]</b> Y. Tzitzikas, N. Minadakis, Y. Marketakis, P. Fafalios, C. Alloca, N. Mountantonakis and I. Zidianaki. <i>MatWare: Constructing and Exploiting Domain Specific Warehouses by Aggregating Semantic Data</i>, 11th Extended Semantic Web Conference (ESWC'14), Anissaras Hersonissou, Crete, Greece, May 2014.
  
−
===TCOM in Italy, Rome, 03.11.2012 ===
+
=== Related Meetings & Minutes ===
−
http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/03.11.2012.MeetingInRome
+
* 3rd TCOM, Rome, Italy, 03.11.2012
 +
** Minutes: http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/03.11.2012.MeetingInRome
 +
* FLOD Ontological analysis virtual meeting
 +
** Minutes: http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/7.12.2012-TLO_FLOD_Ontological_Analysis
 +
* 4th TCOM, Ostende, Belgium, 29.01.2013
 +
** Slides: http://goo.gl/JuCrbV
 +
** Minutes: http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/4th_TCom_Meeting:_25th_January_2013_Discussions_and_Notes
 +
* Semantic Cluster virtual meeting, 13.02.2013
 +
** Documents: http://goo.gl/8wbfTK, http://goo.gl/uPS4Ck
 +
** Minutes: http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/13.02.2013_Semantic_Cluster
 +
* 5th TCOM, Pisa, Italy, 21.03.2013
 +
** Slides: http://goo.gl/mHWYzg
 +
** Minutes: http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/5th_TCom_Meeting:_22nd_March_2013_Discussions_and_Notes
 +
* 5th TCOM, Rome, Italy, 26.03.2013
 +
** Slides:  http://goo.gl/Kqm25t
 +
** Minutes: http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/5th_TCom_Meeting:_28th_March_2013_Discussions_and_Notes
 +
* 6th TCOM, Skiathos, Greece, 19.06.2013
 +
** Slides: http://goo.gl/SNiw3c
 +
** Minutes: http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/6th_TCom_Meeting:_19th_June_2013_Discussions_and_Notes
 +
* 7th TCOM, Rome, Italy, 15.10.2013
 +
** Slides: http://goo.gl/jL1JZ7
 +
** Minutes: http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/7th_TCom_Meeting:_15th_October_2013_Discussions_and_Notes
 +
* 8th TCOM, Athens, Greece, 04.02.2014
 +
** Slides: http://goo.gl/4MAsqP
 +
** Minutes: http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/8th_TCom_Meeting:_4th_February_2014_Discussions_and_Notes
 +
* 9th TCOM, Heraklion, Greece, 09.07.2014
 +
** Slides: http://goo.gl/1Q3Pph
  
−
=== FLOD Ontological Analysis, 7.12.2012, meeting online ===
+
=== Related tickets ===
−
For the details of the first meeting, please follow the link
+
* #224- Towards a top-level ontology for FAO & IRD, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/224
−
http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/7.12.2012-TLO_FLOD_Ontological_Analysis. This meeting is related to the ticket https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/224#comment:15
+
* #888- FLOD Ontological Analysis, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/888
−
 
+
* #889- ECOSCOPE Ontological Analysis, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/889
−
=== TCOM in Belgium, Ostende, 29.01.2013  ===
+
* #890- TLO Design: First Iteration, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/890
−
 
+
* #891- TLO Implementation: First Iteration, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/891
−
* Agenda and Presentation, please follow the link https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=871757e1-aa21-46f8-ae3b-85b0e6f6d53a
+
* #892- TLO Evaluation: First Iteration, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/892
−
<!-- * For the details of the Semantic Cluster, Minutes of the TLO-Activity at the 4th TCOM imarine in Ostende on 29 Jan 2013: Julien’s Scenario and TLO-Instantiating Plan/Discussion, please follow the link http://bscw.research-infrastructures.eu/bscw/bscw.cgi/d276309/Semantic%20Cluster%20and%20TLO%20ActivitiesVer1.docx -->
+
* #900- TLO Usage: First Iteration, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/900
−
 
+
* #1220- TLO Population: SPD, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1220
−
=== Semantic Cluster Meeting, online, 13.02.2013  ===
+
* #1451- TLO Examples for species and related SPARQL queries, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1451
−
* TLO activities
+
* #1603- The new release of TLO, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1603
−
** https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=70ef515b-2d2a-4258-a78c-9a1931d6ad3b
+
* #1764- TLO Documentation, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1764
−
** https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=cf9341d0-f234-4dc4-96a3-be62fc247b75
+
* #1848- Documentation of the process used for creating TLO-based warehouses, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1848
−
 
+
* #1932- Building the new MarineTLO Warehouse, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1932
−
* Minutes from Leo: http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/13.02.2013_Semantic_Cluster
+
* #2046- MarineTLO Version 3.0.0, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/2046
−
 
+
* #2050- Actions for exploiting the MarineTLO-based warehouse 2, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/2050
−
=== TCOM in Italy, Pisa, 21.03.2013  ===
+
* #2255- Investigation on Automation and quality improvement of the TLO Marine Warehouse, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/2255
−
 
+
* #2261- Constructing the MarineTLO warehouse v3, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/2261
−
* gCube and Production of RDF Data  (FORTH side)
+
* #2319- MarineTLO Version 4.0.0, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/2319
−
** https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=69068055-db9a-4aec-a0ce-fe523c5aa782
+
* #2433- Constructing the MarineTLO-based warehouse v3+, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/2433
−
 
+
* #2807- Constructing the MarineTLO-based warehouse v4, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/2807
−
=== TCOM in Italy, Rome, 26.03.2013 ===
+
* #2982- Supporting the exploitation of MarineTLO-basedwarehouse v4, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/2982
−
 
+
−
* TLO-­‐Acvity: Status, Open Issues and Next Steps
+
−
** https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=f54bc98d-3b2d-4621-8db2-c86680367523
+
−
 
+
−
* Minutes of the Meeting, 27-03-2013:
+
−
** https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=11a89f7b-39f5-4984-bd7f-60bf40029343
+
−
 
+
−
=== TCOM in Greece, Skiathos, 18.06.2013 (LATEST) ===
+
−
* We presented "TLO-related Activities
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=60ecbc87-fee1-4d98-9acb-beb9596289a4
+
−
 
+
−
== Analysis, Design and Implementation ==
+
−
 
+
−
=== FLOD Ontological Analysis ===
+
−
This activity has the primary goal to provide a common understanding of the FLOD ontology network. It has been considered necessary for the development of the MarineTLO. The associated ticket is https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/888
+
−
 
+
−
*'''FLOD Ontological Analysis''', 04-Dec-2012
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=04d81d92-d3e3-41d9-aeaf-605bd5c4ea33
+
−
 
+
−
* '''FLOD Ontological Analysis''', 07-Dec-2012
+
−
** http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/7.12.2012-TLO_FLOD_Ontological_Analysis
+
−
 
+
−
*'''FLOD Ontological Analysis''', 31-Dec-2012
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=55f18f59-d807-474b-aa5a-88b123d0dae8
+
−
 
+
−
=== Ecoscope Ontological Analysis ===
+
−
This activity has the primary goal to provide a common understanding of the ECOSCOPE ontology network. It has been considered necessary for the development of the MarineTLO. The associated ticket is https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/889
+
−
 
+
−
*'''ECOSCOPE Ontological Analysis''', 13-Dec-2012
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=7414845a-942d-4c1d-b343-27caeee15053
+
−
 
+
−
*'''ECOSCOPE Ontological Analysis''', 11-Jan-2013, meeting, online
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=fc7d36b4-96d8-4083-a524-430487ffb5fd
+
−
 
+
−
=== MarineTLO Design ===
+
−
The activities is related to the design of MarineTLO ontology. The associated ticket is https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/890
+
−
 
+
−
*'''Describing the MarineTLO design''', first draft, 21-Dec-2012
+
−
** https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=0233e4b5-b43b-4e0b-9754-a2c299e0cda7
+
−
*'''Describing the MarineTLO design''', second draft, 24-Dec-2012
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=6fe8c22f-1152-4caf-bfbe-47d07339f905
+
−
*'''Describing the MarineTLO design''', a complete report by the end of July 2013
+
−
 
+
−
=== MarineTLO Implementation ===
+
−
The activities is related to the implementation of MarineTLO ontology using OWL 2 language. The associated ticket is https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/891
+
−
 
+
−
* Please look at http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/Top_Level_Ontology#TLO_Products for the versions of the MarineTLO
+
−
 
+
−
*SPARQL endpoints (Virtuoso and OWLIM-Lite)
+
−
**http://62.217.127.213:8890/sparql with graph name http://www.ics.forth.gr/isl/TLObasedDataWarehouse
+
−
 
+
−
**http://62.217.127.213:8080/openrdf-workbench/repositories/TLODataWarehouse/
+
−
 
+
−
*Competency queries
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=4700c39a-922e-48b2-ba2c-fe7e0e2074b8
+
−
 
+
−
=== MarineTLO Usage ===
+
−
Activities related to the usage of MarineTLO (+ references to documents/ wiki pages/ tickets). This activity is associated to the ticket https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/900
+
−
 
+
−
Here, we describe possible scenarios in which MarineTLO can be evaluated. Currently, we identify the followings:
+
−
 
+
−
* MarineTLO as meta-model for FLOD, ECOSCOPE and WoRMS
+
−
** Fact Sheets and Competence Queries
+
−
 
+
−
* MarineTLO as knowledge model for semantic search in X-search
+
−
** Suppose that a user is looking for publications about tuna. Specifically he wants to find experiments that were applied to several species of tuna. So, he submits the query tuna and gets a sorted list of results and various categories of entities like Regional Fisheries Body, Species, FAO Country, etc. User realizes that the category Species may contain interesting entities. He notices that there is an entity with the label skipjack tuna which is a medium-sized fish in the tuna family found in tropical and warm-temperate waters. User wants to learn more information about that species. Specifically, he would like to see other species for which the skipjack tuna is predator or is prey. By clicking the icon next to the entity's name, user is able to instantly (at real-time) retrieve such information. In particular, in the back end, a SPARQL query is sent to the MarineTLO's endpoint asking for that information. Note that the 'Species' have been derived from FLOD, while the properties 'is predator of' and 'is prey of' have been derived from ECOSCOPE's knowledge base. That would be impossible without the exploitation of the MarineTLO.
+
−
 
+
−
=== MarineTLO Evaluation ===
+
−
This activity is related to the evaluation of the MarineTLO ontology. The associated ticket is https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/892
+
−
 
+
−
A required activity for the MarineTLO evaluation is to populate it with concrete instances.
+
−
 
+
−
*To populate just the class Species, please follow the link
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=2e1a3b06-5c2d-4b96-aea0-c43dc53e670a
+
−
 
+
−
*To populate the class Species with predator and prey relationships, please follow the link
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=506fb989-7af4-492e-b654-19f4fd2113a5
+
−
 
+
−
* Competence Queries, 22-03-2013
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=4700c39a-922e-48b2-ba2c-fe7e0e2074b8
+
−
 
+
−
* MarineTLO Populating, 22-03-2013
+
−
**WoRMS-TLO
+
−
***https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=9b36ae7b-bc10-43a2-95d1-3bec294f1c45
+
−
***https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=69068055-db9a-4aec-a0ce-fe523c5aa782
+
−
 
+
−
*MarineTLO Evaluation Report, 22-04-2013
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=4700c39a-922e-48b2-ba2c-fe7e0e2074b8
+
−
 
+
−
== MarineTLO-related Products ==
+
−
 
+
−
=== The Notion of MarineTLO Version  ===
+
−
 
+
−
Each MarineTLO version consists of
+
−
* A release number
+
−
* An .owl file
+
−
* A set of competency queries
+
−
* A short description describing the changes
+
−
* It could also contain a set of mappings between data source and MarineTLO, each of them described as an OWL file
+
−
 
+
−
TODO: We also need a document that contains the scope notes of each class
+
−
 
+
−
=== Evolution Process  ===
+
−
 
+
−
Since last meeting in Rome (26-03-2013), we planned to release a new version every two months (for correcting errors, based on requirements, priorities, usage needs, etc).
+
−
 
+
−
==== Version 1.0.0 released on 26-03-2013 ====
+
−
* Release Number: 1.0.0
+
−
* Documentation of the MarineTLO version 1.0.0 https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1764#comment:1
+
−
* This version of the MarineTLO containing classes, properties and instances to test the MarineTLO over the fact sheet
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=1eb50637-736c-4d37-8604-7544215c989b
+
−
* Competence queries covering the fact sheets
+
−
**https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=4700c39a-922e-48b2-ba2c-fe7e0e2074b8
+
−
* OWL Mappings: FLOD-TLO, Ecoscope-TLO and WoRMS-TLO
+
−
**  https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=5091a8ec-5d0e-4d14-bb61-e71a44e62a7b
+
−
** https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=0745f853-f81c-4317-ac72-b0e78c4fdaeb
+
−
 
+
−
==== Previous TLO Versions ====
+
−
* TLO Version 13/11/2012, https://portal.i-marine.d4science.org/group/data-e-infrastructure-gateway/workspace?itemid=832af2c7-70d2-4ac3-8985-ed1efcaa0a40
+
−
 
+
−
=== MarineTLO-based Warehouses ===
+
−
 
+
−
==== Warehouse 1 (June 2013) ====
+
−
* Virtuoso
+
−
**http://62.217.127.213:8890/sparql with graph name http://www.ics.forth.gr/isl/TLObasedDataWarehouse
+
−
 
+
−
* OWLIM Lite
+
−
**http://62.217.127.213:8080/openrdf-workbench/repositories/TLODataWarehouse/
+
−
 
+
−
==== Warehouse 2 (planned for the end of July 2013) ====
+
−
 
+
−
Ongoing
+
−
 
+
−
* One can browse the current (under construction) Virtuoso MarineTLO-based repository @ http://62.217.127.128:8890/fct/
+
−
** e.g. http://62.217.127.128:8890/describe/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ecoscope.org%2Fontologies%2Fecosystems%23thunnus_albacares&sid=6&urilookup=1 information about thunnus albacares are returned.
+
−
 
+
−
== MarineTLO Related Tickets ==
+
−
 
+
−
=== First Iteration ===
+
−
* FLOD Ontological Analysis: https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/888 '''CLOSED'''
+
−
 
+
−
* Ecoscope Ontological Analysis: https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/889 '''CLOSED'''
+
−
 
+
−
* MarineTLO Design: https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/890 '''CLOSED'''
+
−
 
+
−
* MarineTLO Implementation: https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/891 '''CLOSED'''
+
−
 
+
−
* MarineTLO Results: TLO Usage https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/900 '''CLOSED'''
+
−
 
+
−
* MarineTLO Evaluation, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/892 '''CLOSED'''
+
−
 
+
−
* MarineTLO Population, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1220 '''CLOSED'''
+
−
 
+
−
* MarineTLO Version 2.0.0, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1603 '''OPEN'''
+
−
 
+
−
* MarineTLO Version 2.0.0 Documentation, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1764 '''OPEN'''
+
−
 
+
−
* Documentation of the process used for creating MarineTLO-based warehouses, https://issue.imarine.research-infrastructures.eu/ticket/1848 '''OPEN'''
+
−
 
+
−
* Creation of a new TLO-based warehouse '''ONGOING'''
+

Latest revision as of 10:28, 30 October 2014

Introduction

In a nutshell

One of the main characteristics of biodiversity data is its cross-disciplinary feature and the extremely broad range of data types, structures, and semantic concepts which encompasses. Moreover, biodiversity data, especially in the marine domain, is widely distributed, with few well-established repositories or standard protocols for their archiving, access, and retrieval. Queries like “Given the scientific name of a species, find its predators with the related taxon-rank classification and with the different codes that the organizations use to refer to them", cannot be formulated (and consequently nor answered) by any individual source. To formulate such queries we need an expressive conceptual model, while for answering them we also have to assemble pieces of information stored in different sources. To fill this gap, we have designed and implemented a top level ontology, called Marine Top Level Ontology (for short MarineTLO).

Motivating Scenarios

The availability of a top level ontology for the marine domain would be useful in various scenarios. Below we will describe them.

For Publishing Linked Data: There is a trend towards publishing Linked Data; consequently a rising issue concerns the structure that is beneficial to use during such publishing. The semantic structure that will be presented can be used by the involved organizations for anticipating future needs for information integration, and thus alleviating the required effort for (post) integration.

For Generating Fact Sheets: FactSheetGenerator is an application provided by IRD aiming at providing factual knowledge about the marine domain by mashing-up relevant knowledge distributed across several data sources. Currently, FactSheetGenerator uses only ECOSCOPE and related knowledge stored in other sources (e.g., about commercial codes or taxonomic information) cannot be exploited. MarineTLO could be exploited for advancing this application, i.e., for providing more complete semantic descriptions.

For Semantic Post-Processing of the Results of Keyword Search Queries: Another big challenge nowadays is how to integrate structured data with unstructured data (documents and text). The availability of harmonized structured knowledge about the marine domain can be exploited for a semantic post-processing of the search results (over dedicated or general purpose search systems). XSearch is a meta-search engine that offers semantic post-processing of search results and is able to analyze the returned results by exploiting also the availability of semantic repositories (e.g. SPARQL endpoints). Xsearch could exploit MarineTLO for providing more complete information about the identified entities.

For Enabling Complex Query Services over Integrated Data: MarineTLO can be used as the schema for setting up integrated repositories that offer more complex query services, which cannot be supported by the individual underlying sources. In general, there are two main approaches for building and querying such repositories: the materialized integration approach (or warehouse approach), and the virtual integration (or mediator) approach (more information about these approaches can be found in [Tzitzikas-MTSR'13]). The key point is that in both cases we need a schema and MarineTLO can serve this requirement.

MarineTLO as a product

We used a set of underlying sources for integrating their concepts in MarineTLO. Below we briefly describe these sources, and then describe the ontology MarineTLO and its corresponding releases.

The main underlying sources

Fisheries Linked Open Data: FLOD, created and maintained by Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), is dedicated to create a dense network of relationships among the entities of the Fishery domains, and to programmatically serve them to semantic and traditional application environments. The FLOD content is exposed either via a public SPARQL endpoint[1] (suitable for semantic applications) or via a JAVA API to be embedded in consumers’ application code. Currently, the FLOD network includes entities and relationships from the domains of Marine Species, Water Areas, Land Areas, Exclusive Economic Zones, and serves software applications in the domain of statistics and GIS.

ECOSCOPE Knowledge Base: IRD offers a public SPARQL endpoint[2] for its knowledge base containing geographical data, pictures and information about marine ecosystems (specifically data about fishes, sharks, related persons, countries and organizations, harbors, vessels, etc.).

WoRMS: The World Register of Marine Species[3] currently contains more than 200 thousand species, around 380 thousand species names including synonyms, and 470 thousands taxa (infraspecies to kingdoms).

FishBase: FishBase[4] is a global database of fish species. It is a relational database containing information about the taxonomy, geographical distribution, biometrics, population, genetic data and many more. Currently, it contains more the 32 thousand species and more than 300 thousand common names in various languages.

DBpedia: DBpedia[5] is a project focusing on the task of converting content from Wikipedia to structured knowledge so that Semantic Web techniques can be employed against it. At the time of writing this article, the English version of the knowledge base of DBpedia describes more than 4.5 million things, containing persons, places, works, species, etc. In our case, we are using a subset of DBpedia’s knowledge base containing only fishes (i.e. instances classified under the class http://dbpedia.org/ontology/Fish).

The Marine Top Level Ontology

MarineTLO is not supposed to be a single ontology covering the entirety of what exists. It aims at being a global core model that (a) covers with suitable abstractions the domains under consideration to enable the most fundamental queries, (b) can be extended to any level of detail on demand, and (c) can adequately map and integrate data originating from distinct sources. This approach has two main benefits:

  • reduced effort for improving and evolving it since the focus is given on one model rather than many
  • reduced effort for constructing mappings since this approach avoid the pair-wise mappings between individual metadata formats and/or ontologies.

For the development and evolution of MarineTLO we have adopted an iterative and incremental methodology comprising the following steps: (i) ontological analysis of the underlying sources, (ii) design, (iii) implementation and (iv) evaluation. The activities of each iteration has been monitored by opening the corresponding tickets. The section #Related_tickets contains a list of the tickets that have been opened. For the implementation of MarineTLO we have used OWL 2 (Web Ontology Language) while for the needs of evaluation we used the notion of competence queries.

Releases

In total we have released 4 versions of the MarineTLO. Each release was able to cover various concepts for different sources. Below we report the contents, some basic information, and several links (e.g., documentation) of each version.

MarineTLO Versions
Version Classes and Properties Underlying Sources Concepts covered OWL File Documentation Mappings Competence Queries Release Date
Version 1 17 classes and 8 properties FLOD, ECOSCOPE, WORMS Species, Scientific Names, Predators http://goo.gl/ukxmAv http://goo.gl/kEfp8g http://goo.gl/3sMdwR March 2013
Version 2 57 classes and 22 properties FLOD, ECOSCOPE, WORMS, DBpedia Species, Scientific Names, Predators, Authorships http://goo.gl/JTh8p9 http://goo.gl/Y9bGFy http://goo.gl/I6STNv http://goo.gl/3ZNqb4 July 2013
Version 3 57 classes and 25 properties FLOD, ECOSCOPE, WORMS, DBpedia, Fishbase Species, Scientific Names, Common Names, Predators, Authorships, Ecosystems, Countries, Water Areas, Vessels, Gears, EEZ http://goo.gl/J15OCE http://goo.gl/FygSd6 http://goo.gl/vxESUF http://goo.gl/yTaz7O October 2013
Version 4 127 classes and 81 properties FLOD, ECOSCOPE, WORMS, DBpedia, Fishbase Species, Scientific Names, Common Names, Predators, Authorships, Ecosystems, Countries, Water Areas, Vessels, Gears, EEZ, Bibliography, Statistical Indicators http://goo.gl/Yh1Uot http://goo.gl/KIFY6e http://goo.gl/WU3xkG http://goo.gl/KIFY6e July 2014

References

Related Links/Publications

  • MarineTLO public website http://www.ics.forth.gr/isl/MarineTLO/
  • MarineTLO-based Warehouse wiki page http://wiki.i-marine.eu/index.php/MarineTLO-based_warehouse
  • [Tzitzikas-MTSR'13] Y. Tzitzikas, C. Alloca, C. Bekiari, Y. Marketakis, P. Fafalios, M. Doerr, N. Minadakis, T. Patkos and L. Candela. Integrating Heterogeneous and Distributed Information about Marine Species through a Top Level Ontology, Proceedings of the 7th Metadata and Semantic Research Conference, MTSR'13, Thessaloniki, Greece, November 2013.
  • [Tzitzikas-ERCIM'14] Y. Tzitzikas, C. Allocca, C. Bekiari, Y. Marketakis, P. Fafalios and N. Minadakis. Ontology-based Integration of Heterogeneous and Distributed Information of the Marine Domain, ERCIM News 2014 (96), Special theme: Linked Open Data, January 2014
  • [Tzitzikas-LWDM'14] Y. Tzitzikas, N. Minadakis, Y. Marketakis, P. Fafalios, C. Alloca and N. Mountantonakis. Quantifying the Connectivity of a Semantic Warehouse, 4th International Workshop on Linked Web Data Management, LWDM'14, Athens, Greece, March 2014.
  • [Moutantonakis-PROFILES'14] M. Mountantonakis, C. Allocca, P. Fafalios, N. Minadakis, Y. Marketakis, C. Lantzaki and Y. Tzitzikas. Extending VoID for Expressing the Connectivity Metrics of a Semantic Warehouse, 1st International Workshop on Dataset Profiling & Federated Search for Linked Data (PROFILES'14), in conjunction with the 11th Extended Semantic Web Conference (ESWC'14), Anissaras Hersonissou, Crete, Greece, May 2014.
  • [Tzitzikas-ESCW'14] Y. Tzitzikas, N. Minadakis, Y. Marketakis, P. Fafalios, C. Alloca, N. Mountantonakis and I. Zidianaki. MatWare: Constructing and Exploiting Domain Specific Warehouses by Aggregating Semantic Data, 11th Extended Semantic Web Conference (ESWC'14), Anissaras Hersonissou, Crete, Greece, May 2014.

Related Meetings & Minutes

Related tickets

Retrieved from "https://wiki.d4science.org/index.php?title=Top_Level_Ontology&oldid=20864"